Campaign feasibility: Bellmere Cancer Pavilion campaign
The DonorAtlas team tested the viability of a $60M goal over five years, with a quiet phase from July 2027.
1 · Recommendation
Take a $50M working goal to the board. Your pipeline supports $48M–$54M today.
$60M needs a $10M+ lead gift plus two gifts of $6M. Raise the goal to $60M in March 2028, month 9 of the quiet phase, if a $10M+ lead gift is committed.
Gifts from $50K to $1M have 120–145% of the candidates they need. We recommend spending the 12-month quiet phase on the 17 candidates for the six largest gifts and on finding 4 more.
2 · Gift range chart for $60M
Tiers 1–3 are 4 candidates short. Every tier below them has more candidates than it needs.
The chart sets the lead gift at 20% of the goal and needs three candidates per gift in Tiers 1–2 and four per gift in Tiers 3–8. A candidate has five-year capacity of at least the gift size and a documented tie to Bellmere.
Gifts and candidates by tier
| Tier | Gifts | Tier total | Candidates needed | Candidates identified | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 | 1 × $12M | $12M | 3 | 2 1 short | |
| Tier 2 | 2 × $6M | $12M | 6 | 4 2 short | |
| Tier 3 | 3 × $3M | $9M | 12 | 11 1 short | |
| Tier 4 | 6 × $1M | $6M | 24 | 31 | |
| Tier 5 | 10 × $500K | $5M | 40 | 58 | |
| Tier 6 | 20 × $250K | $5M | 80 | 96 | |
| Tier 7 | 40 × $100K | $4M | 160 | 212 | |
| Tier 8 | 80 × $50K | $4M | 320 | 410 | |
| Tier 9 | Many under $50K | $3M | |||
| Total | $60M | 645 | 824 |
3 · Concentration at the top
The six largest gifts make up 55% of a $60M goal. At $250K, 96 candidates compete for 20 gifts. At $12M, 2 candidates compete for 1.
Cumulative dollars by gift
4 · Lead gift candidates
17% of your constituents with $5M+ capacity are candidates for the six largest gifts (17 of 102).
$5M+ constituents to candidates
54 of the 85 we ruled out give Bellmere little or nothing. The Current State Analysis found the same pattern across your database: Bellmere receives 6% of its $1M+ donors' giving, against 11% at similar hospital foundations. The 8 better suited to a planned gift went to Helen Marsh (planned giving officer).
5 · Candidates for Tiers 1–3
71% of the candidates come from outside your long-time donor and trustee group (12 of 17).
Where the other 12 come from
- 3Westport. 22% of your $1M+ households live there, and the town produced 8% of FY2026 major-gift dollars. You have held no donor event at the Westport outpatient center since it opened in May 2024.
- 2Halvorsen alumni. Former executives and early staff of Halvorsen Instruments, a Norwalk medical-device maker acquired in 2021. 41 of them have $1M+ capacity and 11 have a gift officer.
- 2Karen Lindahl's former portfolio. Lindahl was a gift officer who left your team in March 2023. Her 131 prospects were never reassigned.
- 2Bellmere physicians. 6 of the 14 physicians in the oncology group have $1M+ capacity.
- 3Other research. A grateful patient referral, a board member's business partner, and a donor who gives elsewhere (under $1K a year to Bellmere, $25K+ a year to other nonprofits).
The 17 candidates
We can ask a Ready candidate in the first six months of the quiet phase and a Developing candidate in months 6–12. An Early candidate needs a qualification visit first.
| Candidate | Where we found them | Capacity (5-yr) | Why they are a candidate | Readiness |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 · one gift of $12M2 identified of 3 needed | ||||
| Gregory and Ellen ThorvaldGreenwich | Long-time donor and trustee | $10M+ | $1.5M to the Heart and Vascular Institute in 2019. Gregory is a hospital trustee. | Developing |
| Daniel MarchettiNorwalk | Halvorsen alumni | $10M+ | Sold Marchetti Biologics in June 2025. Gives $10,000 a year. | Early |
| Tier 2 · two gifts of $6M4 identified of 6 needed | ||||
| Catherine and Robert AshbyWestport | Westport | $10M+ | Sold Ashby Cold Chain in March 2025. Catherine was an oncology nurse at the hospital for 11 years. | Ready |
| Raymond and Lucia FerranteNorwalk | Long-time donor and trustee | $10M+ | $1M to the 2018 emergency department campaign. Raymond is a trustee emeritus. | Ready |
| Nadia HollisterDarien | Grateful patient referral | $5M–$10M | $75,000 to breast cancer care in 2025, after $50,000 in 2024. | Developing |
| Albrecht Family FoundationNew Canaan | Lindahl's former portfolio | $10M+ | Grants $1.4M a year, about 60% to health care. One $50,000 grant to Bellmere, in 2022. | Early |
| Tier 3 · three gifts of $3M11 identified of 12 needed | ||||
| William and Dorothy HensleyDarien | Long-time donor | $5M–$10M | 22 consecutive years of giving. Dorothy volunteers in the infusion center. | Ready |
| Charles WhitcombRidgefield | Trustee | $5M–$10M | Vice chair of the Foundation board. $100,000 a year for the last 4 years. | Ready |
| Janet KowalczykGreenwich | Long-time donor | $5M–$10M | Legacy Society member with a documented bequest. | Ready |
| Drs. Samuel and Rita OkonkwoStamford | Bellmere physicians | $5M–$10M | Samuel is on the medical staff. $25,000 a year for 8 years. | Developing |
| Drs. Arjun and Meera PatelNew Canaan | Bellmere physicians | $5M–$10M | Arjun is a medical oncologist at the cancer center. $40,000 to the 2023 radiation oncology appeal. | Developing |
| Rosalind HarkerStamford | Halvorsen alumni | $5M–$10M | Former Halvorsen CFO. Her donor-advised fund has granted $300,000+ to other health charities since 2021. | Developing |
| Peter and Hana LindgrenWestport | Westport | $10M+ | Sold Lindgren Precision Tooling in 2024. Gives $5,000 a year. | Early |
| Miriam CastellanosWestport | Westport | $5M–$10M | Sold Shoreline Dental Group in 2025. $1,000 a year for 9 years. | Early |
| Leonard and Carol AbernathyNorwalk | Lindahl's former portfolio | $5M–$10M | $100,000 in 2017. No contact logged since Lindahl's last visit. | Early |
| Elise MoreauDarien | Gives elsewhere | $5M–$10M | Her foundation has granted $420,000 to cancer research elsewhere since 2022. | Early |
| Gerald and Fiona PruittGreenwich | Board connection | $10M+ | Business partner of a Foundation board member, who has offered an introduction. | Early |
6 · Scenarios
A $50M working goal is $2M above the conservative scenario and $4M below the likely one. $60M needs the $12M lead gift.
Scenario totals
What each scenario needs
| Scenario | Tiers 1–3 | Total | What has to happen |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conservative | $21M | $48M | No gift of $10M or more. Two $6M gifts, most likely from the Ferrantes and the Ashbys, and three $3M gifts from the Ready candidates. |
| Likely | $27M | $54M | The same five gifts, plus $6M from the Thorvalds or Daniel Marchetti in place of a $12M lead gift. |
| Stretch | $33M | $60M | The same five gifts, plus a $12M lead gift. |
Under a $50M working goal, quiet-phase asks stay sized to the $60M chart.
7 · Recommended timeline
Next steps
- Now through June 2027 · VP, Major and Planned Giving
Qualification visits with the 7 Early candidates, starting with Daniel Marchetti, the Albrecht Family Foundation, and the Lindgrens.
- Now through March 2027 · DonorAtlas senior prospect researcher
Find the 4 missing candidates. We search the 31 at $5M+ who have never given, then the 30 Halvorsen alumni at $1M+ with no gift officer, then the 340 unassigned prospects connected to your board members.
- Q1 2027 · VP, Major and Planned Giving
Ask the Ashbys for $5M to name the infusion center. Set the pavilion's naming levels first and hold the top naming for the lead gift.
- Before July 2027 · Chief Development Officer
Feasibility interviews with the 10 Ready and Developing candidates on the case, naming, and timing.
- Quiet-phase months 1–6
Ask the other 4 Ready candidates: the Ferrantes, Charles Whitcomb, the Hensleys, and Janet Kowalczyk.
- Quiet-phase months 4–9
Lead-gift ask to the Thorvalds, the likeliest $12M donors today.
Month-9 decision, March 2028
Agree these criteria with the board on January 8.
| Decision | Where commitments stand at month 9 |
|---|---|
| Raise to $60M | A lead gift of $10M or more, at least two $6M gifts, and $30M or more in total (half of $60M). |
| Stay at $50M | No lead gift of $10M or more, but at least two $6M gifts and $25M or more in total (half of $50M). |
| Extend the quiet phase | Fewer than two $6M gifts, or under $25M in total. Hold the public launch 6 months and add candidates for Tiers 1–3. |
